National Prosperity and the Beggars’ Two-man Colloquium Ik Muo, PhD.


The first set of deranged people along the bush  paths and narrow streets of igbo-land were madmen… and women. Their features were peculiar and certain: unkempt hair,  birthday suites or tattered attires, generally reprehensible  appearance, discussing with themselves, smiling  at or with  unseen folks, dancing to  music which nobody else heard and changing their steps  as the spirit directed, from slow to fast to ‘fast-fast’!. They were  very few in number  and  Ohamasi, the one I knew when I was a primary school pupil at St Anthony’s Catholic Primary School, Osumenyi, was quite intelligent. At a ceremony one day, somebody asked him whether he would eat rice and he responded: oju;, ojuo Ohamasi  na oga-eli rice (Can you imagine somebody  in his right senses asking Ohamasi if he would eat rice!). He believed that the answer was so obvious that no sensible  person  should ask him  such a question. However,  he was not the only sensible madman.  During a campaign trail in 2022, Peter Obi(the P O that you know), said that the best advice he got on how to manage crime in Upper Iweka (the crime HQ  of ana-Igbo as at that time), was from a MAD man! You can obtain the full details from PO, but there was one particular, remarkable  mad man hanging around under Upper- Iweka  Flyover , whom I believed gave him that invaluable advice. If you doubt this, you can take the GTC option( GTC? Go to  COURT!).

 Much later, we had   beggars. There were no beggars in the streets of Igbo-land when I was growing up. Eventually,  the Biafran war of survival turned some of nd’Igbo into beggars, but it was a temporary and situational phenomenon .  And then, we had an influx of beggars  into Igbo land . Today, there are native and ‘foreign’ beggars in Igbo-land and our people believe that  this development evidences that the  Igbo society has sunk to the nadir and  surrendered their natural sense of shame quotient to  market forces. But that is not the issue. The issue is that the beggars have  a good number of features  in common with the mad folks and very often, you cannot differentiate the two  categories . Along the line, we had some mechanics who shared the same physical appearance with mad people, especially their dressings. It got so bad that our people invented a saying  that mechanics have made it very difficult for us to  know those who are really mad( because they look alike). As time went on, some of our young ones started resembling mad people in the name of fashion: disheveled hair, torn clothes, sagged trousers and speaking to themselves.  Nothing evidences their ‘maddity’ as when  they wear earphone ( or other more recent gadgets), put their phones in their pockets and keep on  talking, shouting  or gesticulating along the road. In any case, there is no better sign of madness that somebody would go to the market, buy a trouser and intentionally shred some parts of it. When the manufacturers found that the clothes were better thorn than complete, they started making torn ones for them. And because  they made money from that, they have extended the shredding from the legs to the  buttocks  and  to the tighs!

 I digressed. One man from your village said that they  labeled him a mad because  whenever he wanted to say  a thing, something else would jump out from his mouth!  The core of my intervention is the beggars  colloquium on the   quantum leaps in the Nigerian economy to the extent that countries like Canada,  Norway, Netherlands, Holland  and Rwanda are  doing ‘ jelossy’ against Nigeria.  Indeed, our economic resurgence is now a Guinness Book of Records feat! This did not start in  2026. In the second quarter of 2024, our GDP grew by3.19%,YOY, far higher than the 2.58% in the second quarter of 2023  and 2.98% in Q1.24. The macroeconomic wonder was so celebrated that the  beggars or madmen ( because of their high similarity index) got interested. Their begging- plates  (their main working tools)were  empty; there was no patronage, which to them  evidenced  weak macroeconomic fundamentals. However, contrary to that experienced reality, the government was gloating  about the strong economy as indicated by the GDP growth. So,  one of them ‘ looked’ at the soaring GDP figures and  asked his ‘business partner’  ‘is it really growing’? The despondent partner wearily responded  so I heard! He heard but he did  not  see or  had not yet seen or felt it!

That was the core of the beggars’   ‘two-man colloquium’ . I have presented the discourse of these beggars to executive students in Business Schools  across Nigeria and incidentally, the high net-worth, sane, and sensible   operators of the Nigerian Economy, sided with the beggars: that there was a wide margin between what they heard and what they ‘saw’ ! By the way, how did I know what the beggars were discussing?  As a spirit, it was possible for me to be omnipresent  but I heard it from Asuquo and  the Business Day( 24/11/24). Incidentally, It was not only  the beggars that discussed this  because   somebody that looked like a middle-income fellow ( he   had a neatly decorated dining table   with a tablecloth and  the Whiteman’s cutlery, fork-knife)   wanted to have lunch but when he opened the dish, he only saw a heap of  GDP inside it! In his mind, he was wondering: na GDP I  go chop?    If you doubt me, go and ask  the same Asuquo and his ‘gang’, again

 By Q1’26, the economic miracle was more miraculous than the miracle of Dammam, when Nigeria came from 4-0 down to  equalize within 30 minutes  to the end of the game and won on penalties against  USSR on February 25, 1989. That was FIFA World Youth Championship (U-20) Quarter-Final at Prince Mohamed bin Fahd Stadium, Dammam, Saudi Arabia. Incidentally, it was not just the GDP; ALL macroeconomic indicators  were engaged in undeclared contest to positively outdo each other. And the GDP  growth figure  for  Q2’26 was even more ‘progressive’  at 4.43%, YOY, the fastest pace in a decade. This put the government in an unparalleled d ecstasy, especially as it evidences that ‘the reforms are working’

 Incidentally, it is  not just the GDP that is galloping furiously and positively. This gave the CBN Governor  the chest-beating confidence  to boast about our macroeconomic stability. The stock market has grown to  hitherto unimaginable N164 trn( from N30trn in 2023), which the president sees as an indication of economic growth and stability(7/8/26).  Inflation has fallen from an all-time high of 33.24 % in 2024 to  14.63%  in  September 2026. The government has saved N16trn from subsidy withdrawal and formal remittances stood at $947m as at July, 2026, a little less than CBN target of $1bn. Tax revenue  was  27trn, after a quantum leap of 113% as at July 2026( N12trn in 2023) while  foreign reserves  at $55bn is the  best in the past 18 years. NNPC has contributed $15.3bn to FAAC within 3 years while it contributed  barely $13bn in the previous 23 years, including $0 under Buhari. Even the FAAC  allocations tell an exhilarating story as it moved from N7.85Trn in 2019. to 21.9trn in in 2025. We are also reminded of the NELFUND, which ensured that no student is  left behind and the 2026 ASUU agreement, which was signed 17 years  after  the negotiations  started.

 There are many more reasons to boast as Nigeria becomes an economic Eldorado. We recorded a  remarkable 50.2% surge in  diaspora remittances, from $2.07bn in Jan-Jun 25 to $3,8bn in July 26; fully paid our  dues of $6.3m  to the UN  and its  $3.3bn budget was historically overseen by  our dear Jimoh Ibrahim; and Nigeria ranks 15 amongst  Africa’s  most  economically free countries in 2026. The Minister  of Information told us that the reforms  are laying foundation for national prosperity and that the removal of subsidy and unification of forex rates were courageous and deliberate decisions necessary to stabilize the economy and create opportunities  sustainable development.  The Minister of Finance authoritatively  declared  that the reforms prevented economic disaster, while  Okpebholo of Edo state   who could not read  an ordinary  budget, enthused that these reforms would make Nigeria as strong as UK and US (he forgot to add France!).  APC bases its  chances of winning in 2027 on  BATs  reforms and associated performance while the loquacious Nwike asked  the  opposition not to lose sight of BATs performances. Another  evidence is that the Bank of Industry disbursed N664bn  ( the highest amount ever) to 12501 businesses ( a  25% increase over 2024) and created 1.6m jobs in 2025  Other ‘third-party’   evidences  about  the impact of our reforms include that  51 countries  invested in the  Dangote  IPO   just as Airtel Chairman, Sunii Bharti Mittal, hailed  the floatation of the Naira , which excited foreign investors

The FGN through its   sycophantic –spokespersons, appointees, and sympathizers     who live in another world, are not the only ones celebrating these epochal  developments. The Nigerian Economic Society ( to which I belong  though I am a member in ‘exile’)  in September 2026 awarded the CBN  its Distinguished Organisation Award in recognition of its institutional reforms and contributions to Nigerians macroeconomic stability and development with specific reference to reforms  in the forex market, clearance of long standing Forex  obligations cessation of ways and means financing, bank recapitalization.

These figures are quite impressive and according to BAT, who treated the matter with unpardonable   levity, those who did  not see  this superlative performance, needed eyeglasses, a statement reinforced by his wife who   recommended  special BAT-eyeglasses . He also  chided us for complaining because  Economic hardship and suffering had been  with us before I came on board; it did not begin with  my administration’ However, when you examine these figures, you see some unfortunate developments that made it difficult for the blind man to feel, or the sighted to see, these developments and the key of these factors is the money ( quantity) illusion.  I learnt this concept from Professor Edozien  at UI in 1977. The fact is that the quantity of money is not the same thing with the quality ( value)of money. The FAAC allocation of 2025 is far less than that of 2019  because the  N22trn in 2025($14.9bn) is ‘junior’ to  the N7.8trn( $25,6bn) in 2019. And the core factor in this dynamics is the ‘subsidy is gone’ declaration which the president made when his was overwhelmed by unusual  and strange  courage-spirit  in 2023. It was just the other day that the government promised  to give us an account of the subsidy savings but the figures are estimated to N16trn.


However, the FGN has borrowed and continued to borrow  within  the same period, all debts  characterized by indescribable opacity. Of course, the unprecedented borrowing  makes nonsense  of the  savings.  We removed subsidy so as to  have money to meet our needs  but our borrowings have reached an alltime high. Our debts now stand at  N167trn(June 2026) as against  N160trn in March, ‘26;  while the  Government  just opened negotiations for another $1.5bn loan.   The datails of these debts are unknown and because of the opacity of our financial archtecture, nobody knows where the money goes. The GDP is galloping  forward while more Nigerians are living in penury and while inflation has fallen, it was mostly due to the economic necromancy of rebasing, especially as the government has  assured  earlier that inflation must ‘bow’ . It was like working from the answer to the question. In any case, the price of a crate of eggs is now N6000+  a kg of gas N2000 and a tankful of Corola is at 65000( depending on where you buy from), relative to N1200 and N300 and 12000 during the Buharian era. Lasisi Olagunju spent N212000  to fuel his car within  12 days and  wondered ‘If merely getting to  work- consumes  the earnings from work, what exactly is the reason for working’? I spend  about N75000  to fuel my car within five days  and I started wondering if I was working-and living-for fuel. Furthermore, the Manufacturers Association of Nigeria has said emphatically  that the falling inflation has not reduced  the members’ production costs.

Two developments that I relate well with are the NELFUND programme and the  the  largess resulting from the ASUU agreement of 2026. Both developments are enviable because, it could have been worse. But somebody  likened the NELFUND programme to  a person who pushed you into the river and then trew a life-saving jacket at you. If you check the what school fees were by 2023 and what they are today, you  will appreciate that the marcroeconomic environment created by the ‘reforms’ jerked up the avarage level of school fees and the FG then offered the loans to cushion the effects of what it had caused , for those who applied, and who will repay someday.

On the ASUU largess, I wish to rely on one   Amoka, who recently gave a graphic  detail.In 2005, the net salary of an Assistant Lecturer was about ₦37,000($280), N57000 in  2006.( $445) and N110000 in 2009( $738). By 2022,  the ₦110,000 was worth only about $246  and after subsidy removal in 2023 and naira devaluation, ₦110,000 dropped to as low as $73.. By 2026,the AL’s  salary was increased to roughly ₦250,000, which is $180.   A professor under PMB earned N419,000 (419? about $900+), which crashed to $277  in 2023 and raised to  N1m( $750) in 2026, which is still significantly less than 2023 levels.  I don’t know whether to ‘laff’ or to cry .( Read  Nigerian University Lecturers and the Self-Normalisation of Poverty)


The  chest-beating about our national prosperity  was raised to the ‘nth’ level by the president during his 2026 ‘independence’  speech   as he gloated that our economy had grown by more than 4%, oil theft was down, inflation had fallen substantially, our reserves have been rebuilt, our forex market stabilized and that the country recorded the highest revenue from non-oil export, exceeding $6bn’ For the first time, I  agree with him as I ask: Na statistics we go chop? Na hope, macroeconomic stability, GDP figures, and Reserves, we go chop?   Yet we have not seen the food he promised to put on the table! These questions are germane because in the same speech, he said, a as if he just got into power, that  our priority is to bring down the cost of living by lowering the cost of production. He thus admitted that the costs of production  and living are still high. Before then, he had asked us ( from France)  to remain hopeful and  give him  more  time to complete his reforms and adress the challenges facing the country. The recent 90-day emergency economic rescue package which followed the tokenistic discount on fuel prices ( after which NNPC increased fuel prices)indicate that FGN  knows that the reforms are far from yielding the desired results. Ogun Sate government has also followed suit by  introducing some palliatives

 So, where  does, the money go? Where did the  ‘real money’ from non-oil export go? He also told us that  our economic anemia did not start with him, just as he told us earlier that there had always be hunger in the land( exposing his high insensitivity quotient) but as at 28 May 2023, I never had to take a bank loan to fuel my car or to travel by public transport from Ijebuode to Igbo-Ukwu. I could even do big-man and fly down, avoiding the Benin-Asaba route, which now showcase   Umahi’s famed infrastructure miracles. I could feed my family  without destabilizing my  peace of mind and the number of formal and informal beggars were manageable. I am not hypertensive but  today anytime I need to buy anything,  especially  fuel and drugs, my heart starts dancing to a music played by market forces.

And the foundation of all this was the subsidy is gone declaration (and there is evidence that subsidy was still being paid  for a long while in the  baptismal name of cost recovery) and incidentally, as other countries take steps to contain the cost of fuel and diesel, we are being asked to  bear the brunt, be patient and hopeful. The latest counties that disciplined  high fuel prices are Germany and Israel, with the Israeli PM vowing  that they would ensure that  fuel prices did not soar in Israel even though they were soaring all over the world

Fuel prices are rising in Nigeria while other countries are ‘ cutting taxes, subsidizing fuel, capping prices, releasing strategic reserves, relaxing regulations and strong-arming oil companies’   Here is a global  review on the matter On Friday, October 2, the G7 agreed to release 100 million barrels of diesel and crude oil from emergency reserves to bring prices down. Ireland cut petrol taxes by 27 cents per liter and diesel taxes by 32 cents. Spain proposed relief of up to 30 euro cents per liter. South Korea imposed a fuel-price ceiling. Brazil has subsidized gasoline and cut taxes. Italy leaned on major oil companies to cap petrol and diesel prices. Kenya cut VAT on petroleum products. Yes, while  the world fights costly petrol, Tinubu defends it(Farooq Kperogi) and this is in a situation where our income  has been so ravaged by inflation that it cannot avail much. A liter of fuel costs about the same thing in Nigeria and US ( 1450-1550).  But while  the lowest-paid American  nets about $ 1,160 Monthly(N 1,543,612 Naira), his Nigerian counterpart  received the new improved wage of N70000( about $52). Thus while the yankeeman can afford  989 litres of fuel with his monthly salary,  a Nigerian at minimum wage can only afford  46 litres! As a pained Nigerian lamented, we copied their  fuel price, but not their salary. And as we  continue wait( somebody calls it the economy of WAITING), I ask, how many of us would be alive by the time  BAT completes his ‘good works’ and as Lasisi Olagunju asked ‘how long must an exausted people wait for your morning and how many will still be standing when your  promised dawn finally breaks?

I  wish to summon  many witnesses who agree with the beggars that they hear of, but do not see, the growth. The first is the  Budget and Economic  Planning  Minister, who agrees that the reforms have created a cost of living crises( Bwala & Bayo cannot admit this much) though he argues that  it is esential for sustainable and inclusive growth.  Of course we all know that the growth has been MORE exclusive than ever, with  the rich getting obsecenly richer. Business Day refers to the whole thing as policies without the people( 13/2/26) while the Guardian authoritatively states that the  economy is growing but people are not feeling it as standard of living tell different stories. Paul Ibe argues that no matter how delicsious it is, Nigerians cannot eat the GDP. And while the NES gave the CBN an award, the Charttered Institute of Bankers felt other wise  as it argued  at its  last bankers conference that  the improving macroeconomic indicators will amount to little if they do not ‘touch’ the people.  The knel of its argument ia that ‘The true test iswhether sronger fundamentals translate into lower living costs  more jobs, higher real incomes affordable credit, reliable public service and reduced poverty. Macroeconomic progress must therefore be felt at the micro level in households, small bsinesses and the daily lives of ordinary Nigerians. One of my friends, Dr Idon Alabi  resurrected Billy Dudly, one of the finest academics  that I had the frtune of meeting in UI( I don’t know whether he was among  those whom IBBdescribed as teaching what they were not paid to teach)  who  once  stated that the key questions are  what is happening to abject poverty, chronic umemploymentand wider income inquality  He then posited that  what is at play is  data massaging or  manioulation  and that  since 2023, the Dudlian trio of employment. poverty and incolme inequality  had gone from ‘bad to mbadamba’!


The Center for the Promotion of Private Enterprise   holds that ‘even though inflation had eased, prices remain significantly higher, with reform-induced shocks eroding purchasing power and businesses under higher operational costs… yet to translate sufficiently into relief for households and businesses’ and advised government to go beyond stabilization and  urgently pursue  productivity-driven reforms’ The Nigerian Employers Consultative Assembly  agrees with CPPE, holding that The success of the reforms should be measured by improvements on citizens welfare, business operations and job creation rather than increased government revenue alone; the  ultimate measure of success should be tangible benefits to Nigerians  stating that  rising energy and transportation costs, weak purchasing power and inadequate infrastructure place enormous pressure on enterprises, threatening sustainability, constraining expansion and placing jobs at risk 

Dakuku Peterside agrees that dificult reforms may be necessary but  posits that  ‘ their legitimacy depends on honest explanation, fair burdens, protection for vulnerable households and willingness to correct mistakes and concluded that ‘ Reform must be tested agaisnt everyday transactions’ Babafemi Ojodu  lamented that ‘ hardship has become the defining experience of too many Nigerians… Even when some indicators are improving. The question you must ask yourself is whether that progress can be felt in  an ordinary household. A parent who cannot pay school feesor  buy medicine cannot live on a projection of future relief. Progress must mean food on the table, a child in school, treatment for the sick and a reasonable chnace to earn a living. He asked the President to reviw his policies with the household in mind. Examine the cumulative burden of fuel prices, transport costs, and the rising cost of basic foods   The 2026  Nigerian Financial Inclusion Report indicates 73% inclusion, more than the 70% target but only 30%  is financially health, leaving 60m people financially vulnerable or merely coping. Access to bank finace and fintech has not improved the financial wellbeing of Nigerians

Alh Rotinwa, a former Head of the Civil Service of the Federation argues that  ‘Growth that does not reward the populace is not an answer;  Rising cost of living created a widening gap between wages and the cost of essential goods and services makes it necessary for government to focus on measures to improve workers purchasing power.  Regretting that in Nigeria, a Permanent Secretary cannot afford a new car and a used one costs  N30m and we still speak of growth

 So,  where do we go from here? Lassisi Olagunju regretted that there is prosperity in the treasury but penury in the market place  and warned that  we were  approaching  ‘with evil irresponsibility, the inevitable time when unless we do something, to stop it, men will be hunting men through the ruins for food’(The Petrol Fire on our roof. Lasisi Olagunju. Monday, 28/9/26). If governments across the globe  understand that  their citizens cannot simply be abandoned to ferociousforces of the  market as they effect fuel, why does Nigeria argue differently?  Nigeria failed  fiscal transparenccy test for two years running, because  budget does not match reality,  audit gaps exists, and te commonness of  opaque procurement practices. And so, even when growth is high, there is no transparency to see where the money goes.  Furthermore, FG borrowing from domestic sources rose by 90.5% YOY( August 25-26) therefore raisng the cost of  credit and squeezing businesses out of the credit market

 As another  compatriot argued Nigerians cannot easily deny  the testimony of their own stomachs, pockets and daily experiences; poverty is no a theory to the hungry, insecurity is not a statistics to the family whose breadwinner is in the warm embrace of kidnappers, unemplyment is not a political slogan for the graduate who is jobless years after the  celebretory  signing out and inflation is not a macroeconomic abbsrraction for the mother who can no longer afford the food she comfortably bought 3 years ago. You cannot continually tell the people that the economy  is improving when their daily experiences tell thenotherwise.

 And another,  Nigerians cannot eat GDP;  they cannoit take improved trade figures to the market and exchange them for a bag of rice, they cannot use rising government revenue to pay their childrens school fees, they cannot cook forex reserve for dinner and vthey cannot feed their families with the repeated government assurances that the economy is in the right trajectory. For many Nigerians, their economic realities remain brutally different from the picture painted by government statistics

 My usual purpose is to draw government attention to what is not going on well. I admit that I am an ancient economist but I know that there is a gulf of difference between growth and development, which impacts on quality of life, education, health care,, lower inequality and inclusivity as against increase in quantity of output.  I do not advice much because they know what is wrong and what to do. A government that removed fuel subsidy but ignored it’s the corruption dynamics  does not need any advice. It knows what it is doing because it knows where the dead bodies are buried. But since people always ask: what do you  advise, I say: go beyond statistics, ignore the quantity illusion, go for development, not growth and always remember that the people are  central to all politics and economics. I have spoken.


By the way,  with  saintly Ibrahim Jimoh representing us at UN, Nwike’s son a corporate land broker at Abuja, Yahaya Bello an APC senatorial candidate, Akpabio as the #3 man in Nigeria,  while Ministers purchase their appointments  and recoup their investments from their budgets, the war against corruption is still RAGING as the President  recently directed the judiciary to review prosecution strategies,  address procedural loopholes exploited by PEPs( Politically Exposed Persons) and organized crime groups to delay or frustrate criminal trials. Furthermore, the man who  assured us of 24/7 power supply has  solarized his office  and asked state governments to sort out our power issues!



- Ik Muo, PhD. FCIB. Department of Business Administration, OOU, Ago-Iwoye. 08033026625

Like| Comment| Share

“Find a great mentor, someone who has already been through the many challenges of being an entrepreneur..” -Jodi Levine

Entrepreneurship in Practice: Cases, Challenges and Lessons By IK, MUO PHD is now available on Amazon, since 14/5/21. Click here to view  Available for order  +2348033026625 | Delivery: Worldwide

Comments