The speech that was NOT and… Continuing from where PMB Stopped - Ik Muo, PhD.

 

 Thoughtless words can wound as deeply as any word but wisely spoken words can heal; kind words are like honey; sweet to the taste and good to the health( Proverbs, 12:18 &16:24)

I am in love with a Harvard Business  Review case study, titled ‘The team that was NOT’ ( Suzzy Wetlaufer, HBR, November-December, 1994; hbr.org)and I exploit every opportunity to deploy it for optimal impact. It is about a team that was NOT a team because it lacked everything required for team effectiveness:  there was neither  mutual respect nor strong foundation, the members were rowing in different directions, there were some toxic members,  the leader was not sure of himself  wdg(WDG means welu dili gaba; the Igbo version of ETC). Consequently the team faltered and could not meet its deliverables. The speech by BAT on 4/8/24  was not a speech, and particularly, for a time like this. Indeed, it was ‘a speech that was not’  because it  did not hit the target and it was more like a campaign speech.  It was not even a good speech to be delivered on a Monday morning. The nation was (and is still) hurting, and the youths had given a long notice of protest( good for Guinness Book of Records). 

The government, instead of genuinely striving to deflate the rising tempo of angst and mass mobilisation,  organised anti-protest protest (another Guinness Book of Records affair) using procured, deceived  and willing participants.  Some women were  invited to Abuja for empowerment only to be given anti-protest posters!  Even the promised mobilisation fee was not paid! But some willingly participated in this charade, a perfect example of the oppressed acting for the benefit of their oppressors. This was micro bribing.  The government then engaged in macro-bribery:  minimum wage, South East Development Commission,  everything became about rice, which was offered in selected places for N40000 (civil servants bought and resold theirs), N50000 for Niger Deltans, more money transfers, and massive food importation).  Our dear BAT summoned meetings upon meetings (including with Traditional Rulers, where he told them that he bought the throne with his money), where attendees were mobilised to speak  against the protest and to dissuade their people from participating. Indeed, there was a cacophony of voices against the protest. Unfortunately, the falcons REFUSED to hear the falconers.


Known agents of Government blamed Ndi’Igbo for  being responsible for a protest that was yet to start.  The protest was politicised and tribalized, with people asked to go and demonstrate in their states.  Onanuga was at his best in this regard even though  Ajuri Ngalale declared that the Government could not stop people from protesting. Many people appealed to the youths to give BAT more time. But his frenemy Bwala, had declared   long before now that nothing would come out of ‘more time for BAT’. Security agencies were speaking from multiple sides of the same mouth, threatening, soft-pedalling, issuing guidelines, undertaking ‘shows of strength’ but they did nothing when  some of members of the  Emilokan  household started the ‘Igbo must go movement’( IMGM).  LASG dissociated itself from the IMGM  while the FG asked them to stop it... nothing more! However in UK, two people who promoted anti immigrants sentiments were jailed  within 72 hours. Adeyinka grandson was also  jailed for 4.5 years for anti-Igbo  crusade in 2022. In Nigeria,  Onanuga, Oluomo and gang, have done so brazenly and got away with it. This unknown group will also get away with it. The genocide-friendly campaigns are against full-blooded Nigerians and for no crime except that they are Nd’Igbo. So, immigrants in other climes are better protected than some citizens in Nigeria. The Chief of Defence Staff, General Musa,   left his challenged security duties  and became  an emergency economic advisor to BAT, informing us that that the government cannot do much with limited resources in just a year; financial advisor of BAT.

As all these were happening, our dear BAT  was mum. May be ,as a Master Strategist, he  believed that he had it all  covered. However, the request  for him to talk to the people intensified and on 4/8/26, he spoke.  There were deaths,  lootings, including one fellow who looted police signboard in Kano  (some people call it pro-looting as against protest), security breaches here and there,  highhandedness of the security forces,  and the  display  of Russian flags. A commentator had quipped that if the Russian flags were flown in the DOT part of the country, it would have been operation gwo-gwo-gwon-gwo! Sure, people protested for different reasons; hunger in the land (a woman came with an empty pot because there  was nothing to cook), bad governance, regime change, plain  criminality,  and other sundry reasons like  the fellow who  demanded for subsidy on  illicit drugs and a woman who blamed bad governance for the loss of male-attractiveness hence her inability to be married  at 37! Another did not want to protest but reminds them that hunger dey!

The looting in the North  was so much that one  person looted a police sign-board! Lasisi Olagunju devoted  a column to the  protesters of the North( Tribune, 5/8/24) who did  what locusts do to farms. They attacked and looted at least one mosque and at least one church; they hammered concrete slabs and squeezed iron  rods for sale, well-paved roads suffered their anger because the beauty of the asphalt offended them. In a library they stole dustbins and spared books because trash is valuable, book is worthless. They attacked private and public buildings, they looted doors, wrenched windows off their hinges and stole installed tiles. They are a perfect proof of what the unbuilt child will ultimately do to well-built structures.


However the only things  related to the protest  in the speech  that was NOT, were condolences for the death caused by his agents, asking the youths to go home to create a conducive environment for dialogue ( You may ask ASUU and NLC  how  ‘creating a conducive environment for dialogue’ worked for them), asking security men to maintain law and order( which they did VERY well, forgetting to follow necessary conventions). May be it was in the process of maintaining law and order  that they invaded the NLC office; something that was NOT done even during the military regime! He also took a jab at the enemies of democracy!  Even though he declared that I have heard you loud and clear, understand your pains and frustration, govt will listen and address these concerns, he did not offer any olive branch; he did not address ANY of the demands of the protesters or even the issues bothering most Nigerans including those who did not join the protest; he also did not provide the protocol and procedures for the promised dialogue! He then   committed  95% of the time on listing ALL the wonderful things his government had done in the past 1 year with promises of more to come. That is why I argue that it was more of a campaign speech! Incidentally, many people ( no be meooo!) have itemised the lies or non-truths in the speech. Rudolph Okonkwo identified 10 non-truths in the speech while Bolaji Akinyemi saw it as bullet for bread. Even his friend,  Wole Soyinka, whom he will soon rename Nigeria after, fired a very bombastic shot: that  serving  bullets when bread is needed is ominous retrogression and a prelude to revolution

However, I must admit that he has, once-more, fulfilled one of his core promises; to continue from (and improve on) where PMB stopped. This evidences adherence to the principle of DWYSYWD ( Do what you said you would do), which is a mark of integrity. I will share with you, some of the speeches that PMB made in difficult times  during his rulership, for you to  compare the former with the later.

 In a speech on 12/6/20, PMB told us how excellently Nigeria was performing on all fronts, especially in terms of  security, anti-corruption and economy. But when I looked at the front pages of our news media within the week, I was left wondering whether I was in the same country of which he spoke so glowingly about (See Ik Muo; Buhari’s June 12 Speech: A Front-Page Analysis; 26/6/20). It was around that time that Nosa Igiebor lamented that  the Buhari Administration operate ‘in a parallel world where alternative facts rule and reality is totally distorted….. their narrative, collides violently with our own reality’.

During the EndSARS  crises, the nation was on fire but the president kept his cool. We begged him to address us and when he eventually did, very reluctantly on 22/10/20, there was no empathy, no assurances and  no outline of actions; he didn’t calm frayed nerves and he ordered the youths to go home, telling them in a   coded language: just try it again!  He did not even mention the Lekki bloody affair, which had caused local and global outrage neither did he mention the infiltration of the peaceful protest by ‘unknown thugs’.  But he had time to boast of his landmark achievements, including tradermoni and other such integrity-challenged programmes( See Ik Muo, A nation in turmoil, A president who doesn’t speak often & giving the monkey a cup of water!29/10/20)

 At a time, our security situation became so precarious that cries for help have echoed nationwide as it appears all our defences have crumbled( Isaiah,22:5&8).  Nigerians, forgetting their previous experiences, started demanding and begging their president to address them and again he did not disappoint. Using the LIFO principle,( Last In First Out) I wish to start with his June 12 outing.  I did not ‘see’ anything in the speech, except that his commitment to ‘bequeath a sustainable democratic culture,… pursuit of a fair society remains unshaken,  his desire to see that Nigeria remains a country for each and every one of us has never been stronger; he acknowledged the notions of marginalisation and agitations for constitutional amendments, and lifted 10.5m people out of poverty in the past 2 years. For most of these avowals, we all know the reality but on the poverty lifting claim, The World Bank and BusinessDay responded on our behalf. They did not say that PMB lied because nobody wanted the Twitter Treatment;; they rather proved statistically that he was economical with the truth. Anyway, he was not the one speaking; he just said what he had been asked to say.

The day he actually spoke was on the Arise TV outing; where nothing was pre-recorded and there was nobody to urge him on, when we heard from the horse’s mouth and when  he spoke out of the abundance of the heart (Luke,6:45)( see  Buhari, Out of the Abundance of the heart the man speaks). He asked the governors to go and sort out the security challenges themselves (when his agents are undermining their efforts) and yet he agreed with Malmi on open grazing; ordered the reopening of the grazing routes (a Northern law that has nothing to do with the South), with its divisive properties and that the murderous herders, who are NOT terrorists, are  foreigners. He  distinguishes foreign from local , criminal from non-criminals Fulanis; he  also knows that all Hausas or Northerners  do not belong to the Bako Haram . However to him, all Nd’Igbo, including his ministers( Onyeama Ngige and Njoku) Allen Onyema( AirPeace), Chidi Anyaegbu,( Chisco) Innocent Chukwuma,( Innoson Motors) Obianodo( Young Shall Grow) Prof Soludo, Ngozi Okonjo-Iwealla ( DG, WTO), Ogbonnaya Onu, Stan Ekeh, Okwadike IgboUkwu, Engr Edu Okeke  (Azura Power). Profs Anya and Utomi, Chimamanda Adichie, Philip Emeagwali, and Chika Nwobi, are profiled as IPOBians,. He also stated  that IPOBians( Nd’Igbo) do not have the training, competence and experience to command the army, lead the NNPC  or become  the Secretary to the Government of the Federation because these positions are earned and that  even seniority does not  matter. And then, he made the unfortunate DOT declaration and we  automatically changed from being  Nd’Igbo to Ndi-DOT!

He   explained how his actions or inactions during EndSARS improved the climate for FDI(???) and reminded us that the EndSARSers wanted to ‘coup’ him out of office, that the youths should behave if they wanted jobs, blamed the PDP government for dwindling economy and unsustainable debt burden and informed that his Niger-Centrism is because he has cousins there and that we will benefit from their economy. Instead of unlocking the humongous wealth within, we are looking onto Niger Republic. Niger can only give what they have, which is poverty! An example of our economic collaboration with Niger  Republic is the case of the Nigerien young man, Aboubakar Hima who  further impoverished us by vanishing into thin air with our commonwealth to the tune of  $394m,9.9m and N369m (you can calculate the billions involved).

I have just  recalled some of the GREAT PMB speeches, which were mostly off-tangent. This  address of BAT on the End-Hunger protests, will surely rank among his GREATEST speeches. If you do not agree, Go To Court,  but be it known to you that the courts  and the judiciary system, have been  completely ‘captured’

 Meanwhile,   INEC has announced the results and the President won  both the battle and the war! How? Northern youths,  represented by Arewa Youths Consultative Movement, have passed a vote of confidence on BAT and Akpabio. This was on August 10, when the protest ended and when norther youths were mourning their members who died during the protest.  The President of AYCM declared that their empirical research has revealed that  Tinubu and Akpabio have made monumental achievements geared towards economic recovery and the promotion of unity and peaceful coexistence in the country. ( I gleaned it from The Nation!!!)Akpabio had declared that while  the youths would be protesting,  he, and his cohorts, would be eating! The youths he ridiculed and mocked  are the same ones passing the vote of confidence on him. The National Council of States  and the Nigerian Governors Forum have also passed Votes of Confidence on BAT, urging him to CARRY_Go!!! Why did our youths protest in the first instance? When everything was, and is, working so well?  We live in  DIFFERENT worlds and We perceive differently!!!


Other Matters

On 12/8/89, ‘We DID’. 35 years later, we are still DOING. It is the Lord’s doing!

                                               Then                   and                  now

 Thanks to those who rejoiced with and prayed for us to keep on DOING!

It goes for N5000 for delivery within Nigeria.  For delivery, subscription or advertisements, contact 08033026625 or 08037116817

Ik Muo, PhD. FCIB. Department of Business Administration, OOU, Ago-Iwoye. 08033026624

Like| Comment| Share

“Find a great mentor, someone who has already been through the many challenges of being an entrepreneur..” -Jodi Levine

Entrepreneurship in Practice: Cases, Challenges and Lessons By IK, MUO PHD is now available on Amazon, since 14/5/21. Click here to view  Available for order  +2348033026625 | Delivery: Worldwide

 








Comments